Monday, June 25, 2018

The Service of Vespers

Solemn Mass? It has been six years since I last saw one. Vespers? I have not seen the service of Vespers in five weeks and I miss it much more. I would even go as far as to say I could live with a spoken Mass provided I could attend Vespers every Sunday evening, the perfect consummation to a perfect day.

Last year I wrote about my recent re-discovery of Compline after sticking to the Major Hours and also the Byzantine Office for several years. Compline, for myself and for many readers, was our initiation into the Divine Office if only because it could be said before bed, it was simple, and it hardly changed day to day. Vespers, however, was for myself and another reader, our introduction into liturgical prayer properly speaking. Raised in the 20th century Roman Church, the parish Mass can be taken for granted, new or old rite. We are required to go to Mass and we can find its celebration more or less heuristic and devout depending on our own disposition and devotion. The Office, unlike Mass, is seamless and can only really be celebrated one way, without pause for theatrics, spoken prayers, or deliberate gestures. It begins as it ends, imploring aid for those who need it: Deus in adiutorium and Fidelium animae. The service may not confect the Holy Eucharist, but it does enter into Eternity as much as the Mass and into the proprietary nature of the day even more so than the Mass for great feasts.


First, at the Oxford Oratory, I heard Vespers again where I first heard the service at all. The rite was Sunday after Ascension according to John XXIII's rubrics, which Oxford follows more stringently than the mishmash service at Brompton. "Back in the day" there were probably more people from the 11AM Solemn Latin Paul VI Mass who went to Vespers than people who went to the 1962 low Mass at 8AM. The reasons are probably varied: traditionalists are very likely to have families in tow, which is a complication toward the evening; people who go to the high Mass are likely more interested in grand liturgical gestures; perhaps the greater attendance at the new rite ensures that even with a lower percentage of people interested in Vespers a greater number will be from the new Mass. Regardless, Vespers and Benediction still gathers about 50 souls. The music was Gregorian plainsong according to the Solesmes method. The provost, Fr. Daniel Seward, officiated.


The most pleasantly surprising service was Vespers according to Paul VI's Liturgia Horarum in Latin at Westminster Cathedral, where a reader left me after spending an afternoon in London with a bottle of wine. Westminster Cathedral, in the fashion of the more proper Anglican institutions, maintains both a professional male choir and a school of young boys who sing the Office daily; the choir also sings a high new rite Latin Mass daily. The singing is some of the best I have ever heard in person and a far cry better than the Sistine Screamers. Vespers was for (what should have been) the Octave Day of the Ascension of Our Lord. The theme of the new rite Vespers, which is the only public celebration of the new Office I have ever seen in my life (like the Latin Novus Ordo it is rarer than its old rite counterpart), began with the Veni Creator hymn, an odd choice given that Pentecost was some days away. Then were sung three psalms, or possibly psalm fragments, then a vernacular reading, and a priest recited some intercessory prayers. All in all, this Vespers lasted 20 minutes and perhaps 30 people attended, although 150-200 probably came in for the following Mass.


The Kyrie from the evening Mass at Westminster Cathedral, set by Orlande de Lassus

Last came Vespers for Pentecost Sunday at the Brompton Oratory, sung alternatively by their professional choir and the Fathers in choro. The provost, Fr. Julian Large, celebrated with the aid of four coped assistants who intoned the antiphons before an assembled congregation of probably 100-150. Vespers of Pentecost Sunday may be the most beautiful in the entire Roman rite. The antiphons are brisk, succinct, generally in a major key, and come as powerfully as the Holy Wind of which they speak. Is there a more moving hymn than the Veni Creator

I have known Byzantine Vespers these past six years, the psalter of which never changes day to day, which the exception of odd times of year like Bright Week. The Roman Vespers has considerable variation with seasonality and the odd major feast. Also, whereas the Greek service tends to flow continuously, Roman Vespers builds up like the last movement of Beethoven's Ninth Symphony, culminating in the offering of incense at the altar during the Magnificat. A rediscovery of the old Suffrages and Commemorations might re-orient the Magnificat into the climax of the service rather than the bittersweet end that it generally is.

I wish Vespers would proliferate the United States. For those with a well equipped parish it may well be the next thing to ask of one's pastor. If he asks why the service should be scheduled when so few would attend just answer, "For God's sake, man."

9 comments:

  1. When I was at sixth form I used to go up to the sung Vespers in Westminster Cathedral almost daily, purely for the excellence of the choir. On Mondays I would attend Vespers at 5 o'clock and then walk to Corpus Christi in Covent Garden for Mass. In those days it was (and, so far as I know, still is) the only regular sung Mass anywhere on a weekday in London, come feast or feria.

    My first Solemn Vespers was at the CIEL conference at Merton College in 2006. I remember feeling amazed by it, and thinking it so much better than commonplace Mass. There were some very distinguished speakers at that conference too. There's a YouTube video of part of the Magnificat here:

    https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Vzq6_IkqWrI

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I saw that clip before and always wondered if it was a special setting of the Magnificat or just a two harmony variation of a normal Gregorian melody.

      Delete
    2. I once emailed someone from the NLM about this. I'll have a look through my inbox/archive to see what they said and will get back to you.

      Delete
  2. To its credit Westminster Cathedral is one of the few Catholic cathedrals in Europe to maintain choral offices on weekdays

    ReplyDelete
  3. I've been going to the 1962 mass regularly for almost 15 years, and nearly exclusively for more than 10. We're fortunate enough to have solemn masses a couple of times per year, and I love them.

    But due to lack of availability, I've never once been to sung vespers according to the preconciliar forms. This post really makes me realize how much I've been missing out!

    ReplyDelete
  4. Yeah, Corpus Christi Maiden Lane is excellent. The schola had an emergency when I went, but I was pleased that they just assume a man in the pew on Monday night is willing to serve if asked. (I came during the Easter holidays.)

    The third chant in the LH Vespers is a New Testament canticle, modeled on the one at Lauds, except that outside of the Gospel canticles, there aren't any in the NT.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Yes and those two from the Gospel are already used in the Major Hours.

      Does the LH just make passages from Saint Paul into music?

      Delete
  5. Our parish (SSPX) had sung vespers for the Feast of St. Michael last year. Of the 300+ families in the parish, only my family showed up. We’ve not had any vespers since.

    For whatever reason, the local ICRSS parish is having Sunday vespers next month. I plan to go in hopes it will turn into a regular Sunday occurrence.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Marc, Vespers have to be a regular occurrence, not a one-off. The SSPX parishes in Post Falls and S. Marys have Vespers every Sunday (well, they did back in the '90s), and a sizeable number of families would attend. Perhaps 5%-10% of the parish. Regularity is key.

      Delete