Monday, January 7, 2019

A Very Merry Christmas (?!)

Yesterday, January 6, was Armenian Christmas. Today, January 7, is Coptic Christmas. Did I get that right?

These two churches, mysteriously called Oriential (sic) Orthodox, in contrast to the Eastern Orthodox, share Communion with each other, but not the date of Christmas in the United States. The Armenian Church is the last Apostolic Church to adopt the celebration of the Nativity of Our Lord; they are only the last because they have not adopted the feast at all. They observe Christ's birth along with the Baptism in the Jordan and the Wedding Feast at Cana on January 6, the Theophany feast. My own Byzantine parish celebrated that same feast, Theophany, today with an extraordinarily detailed blessing of Jordan Water in a service that resembles the structure of the Divine Liturgy, complete with readings, an Alleluia, a Gospel, a Litany, and a dismissal.

The Coptic Church, especially here, in America, continues to adhere to their own kalendar, which aligns with the Julian system still favored by many Calcedonian Orthodox, which makes today something approximating December 25 on another schema. They will observe the feast of Epiphany on January 19, thirteen days after their Armenian brethren.

Despite what some commentators believe, especially those who wish to impose a universal date for the Resurrection for all Catholics (East and Latin) and Orthodox, either according to the Gregorian kalendar or the Julian one, the disparate celebration of feasts is not an inherent occasion for disunity with the broader Church. If anything, the local observance should be favored over the universal norm, should they differ, if only because of the lesson of today's (or yesterday, or the 19), that Christ came to sanctify and save the world, not to confuse it. It would be better, in this writer's humble opinion, to uplift and Christianize the rhythms of our society than to create a parallel world in which they do not exist. Were the pope to announce we would henceforth celebrate Christmas on January 7, the greeting card issuers and toy retailers would smile in having two extra weeks of sales; they would not hang on to the current date.

The ones who have it hardest are those caught between cultures, immigrants more often than not. Our parish will repeat the Divine Liturgy for Christmas on January 7, entirely in Ukrainian, a service more often than not attended by those who adhere to the traditions of the Old World as they live in the New.

Now, will the Armenian Church in New York, St. Vartan's, have mitred deacons today for St. Stephen?

10 comments:

  1. Went to a NO yesterday (the first time in almost 2 years). The priest started ranting about December 25th, belittling the date and praising the (Eastern) Orthodox date. He failed to mention the Julian calendar, so I take it he has no idea yesterday was really Christmas for many EO.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. What a strange thing to mention. Epiphany has so many rich topics on which to demonize. Talking about the date sounds so boring.

      Delete
    2. Wow I meant sermonize not demonize!

      Delete
  2. "The Armenian Church is the last Apostolic Church." How is it "Apostolic"?

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. They may not have been founded by an Apostle, but they are Apostolic in every other sense: their founder, St Gregory the Illuminator, was a bishop; they maintain the ancient structure and community of a proper church; they retain Apostolic succession and traditional Christian doctrine. In short, they practice a form of Christianity that derives from the Apostles' work.

      Delete
  3. Armenians following the (new) Gregorian calendar celebrate Theophany on January 6th, the day of Western rites Epiphany, as their liturgy has never indeed differentiated between Christmas and Epiphany as in other rites. However, St. Stephen's feast is kept on the 25th December. I would be very surprised if there were mitred deacons in New York on that day but would be delighted to be proved wrong. AFAIK mitred deacons are found only in Jerusalem.

    However, there are also still, some (old) Julian Calendar Armenians, not many and they are to be found in some of the most troubled areas of the middle East. They will have kept St. Stephen on Monday (December 25th = 7 January n.s.) and will not keep their 'Christmas', Theophany, until old style January 6th (= 19th January n.s.)

    ReplyDelete
  4. In Ukrainian? Hardly traditional and redolent of the nasty nationalism that seems to maintain a hold on Eastern Christians, uniate or not.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Nationalism is alive and well in Slavic Christianity. The latest circular firing-squad the Orthodox are having over Ukraine is a particularly distasteful illustration of what can eventuate with national churches.

      Delete
  5. RT,

    new reader here. Have you thought about going through your posts over the years, removing the superfluous and simultaneously making compilations of series or themes (official or not) by categories in the sidebar? I find many interesting posts and series, but it's quite a jungle and criss-crossing of links to find the interesting stuff.

    Thanks,

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Welcome to the blog! I have received a few requests for that very purpose over the last few years and may endeavor to do it this quarter.

      Delete